acme-payments/payment-webhook-service PR #142 is needs manual review with HIGH risk. Evidence is needs review. Human approval is required before merge. Source context: MergeGuard, Agent Work Records. PR #142 in acme-payments/payment-webhook-service is needs manual review with high control risk. Complete human review before merge.
Source: MergeGuard + Agent Work RecordsVerification: Needs reviewCurrent authority: blocked platform
Overview
Approval requirement satisfied. Repository verification has not run. Execution transport is disabled. Dispatch remains disabled.
MergeGuard report generated; 3 repo rules summarized; 3 policy checks triggered; 1 protected / 1 sensitive path matches; GitHub Check Preview: failure; PR Comment Preview v2 available; 2 safe warning labels
- Risk level
- High control risk
- Merge recommendation
- Needs human review
- Human review required
- yes
Review Status
Review needs human attention before the work should be trusted or merged.
Repository Connection
Deterministic repository identity and task paths only. Repository metadata, contents, this PR, and GitHub checks were not fetched; repository verification did not run.
GitHub · repository host
acme-payments/payment-webhook-service
Secure Payment Webhook · paths are deterministic task scope, not fetched repository contents.
- Workspace membership
- Workspace Recorded
- Adapter
- github-repository-adapter · github-repository-adapter-v1
- Installation
- Installation Unverified
- Installation ownership
- Installation Ownership Unverified
- Repository ownership
- Repository Ownership Unverified
- Permissions
- modeled · unrequested · ungranted · unverified
- Metadata / contents
- not fetched / not fetched
- PR / checks
- deterministic previews · not fetched
- Webhook
- Webhook Not Configured
- Revocation / kill switch
- Not Revoked / Inactive
- Read / write / execution
- false / false / false
WorkspaceIdentityTrustWorkspace Recorded
GithubHostTrustHost Recorded
GithubAccountIdentityTrustAccount Unverified
InstallationIdentityTrustInstallation Unverified
InstallationOwnershipTrustInstallation Ownership Unverified
RepositoryIdentityTrustRepository Recorded
RepositoryOwnershipTrustRepository Ownership Unverified
PermissionTrustPermissions Unverified
MetadataTrustMetadata Not Fetched
ContentsTrustContents Not Fetched
WebhookTrustWebhook Not Configured
HealthTrustHealth Not Observed
AdapterVersionTrustAdapter Recorded
PolicyBindingTrustDeterministic Preview
ProductionReadinessProduction Not Ready
Inspect deterministic task paths (2)
app/api/payments/webhook.tstests/payment-webhook.test.ts
Risk & Merge Recommendation
High control risk. Recommendation: Needs human review. Approval requirement satisfied. Repository verification has not run. Execution transport is disabled. Dispatch remains disabled..
- Review status
- Needs manual review
- Status detail
- Review needs human attention before the work should be trusted or merged.
- Created
- Jul 9, 07:02 AM
- Mode
- mock
- Origin
- manual demo
- Work type
- security review
- Scope status
- payment paths only
- Agent identity
- Unknown agent
- Action
- preview
- Sender
- deterministic-demo
- Policy checks
- 3
- Policy violations
- 0
- Required follow-ups
- 2
- Recommended follow-ups
- 1
- Repo rules
- deterministic_preview
- Repo rules source
- deterministic:task-policy-snapshot
- Report
- generated
- Comment
- dry-run
- Protected matches
- 1
- Sensitive matches
- 1
- RepoBrain rules
- 3
- Test commands
- 1
RepoBrain policy definition / changed files context
Payment webhook changes are scoped to the webhook implementation and its matching test. Repository verification has not run; the approval requirement is satisfied.
Evidence & Human Review
Evidence checklist
MergeGuard report generated; 3 repo rules summarized; 3 policy checks triggered; 1 protected / 1 sensitive path matches; GitHub Check Preview: failure; PR Comment Preview v2 available; 2 safe warning labels
- Observed evidence: report generated.
- Repository policy: not loaded.
- Policy checks: 3; violations: 0.
- Relevant test commands: 1.
- Warnings requiring inspection: 2.
Verification & test/build evidence
Verification state: Needs review. Test/build evidence is represented by safe counts and labels only and may be draft or simulated in private beta.
Review findings are separate from runner outcomes. Repository commands were not run, and no test or security pass is inferred.
Plan verification-plan-2458e6d26e940ec0 · internal-control provenance: system control · independent verification: false.
- unit_test_runner: not_run (blocked_platform)
- static_security_runner: not_run (blocked_platform)
Open Verification StateHuman approval authority
Generic Review Run recommendation: Human review required (check preview requires review; required reviews: security, owner; 2 required follow-ups).
Approval requirement satisfied. Repository verification has not run, and execution transport remains disabled.
Approval requirement: satisfied.
Evaluated at: 2026-08-12T04:57:55.214Z. Historical Review Run labels remain evidence context, not current authority.
Ledger / Work Record connection
Linked Agent Work Record & Ledger record
This Review Run can be inspected alongside the draft Agent Work Record and derived AI Work Ledger foundations. These are contextual links, not fake record deep links.
Demo record metadata is simulated and uses persisted: false.
Decision boundaries
- Observed evidence
- Safe summary and counts
- System recommendation
- Needs human review
- Current instruction
- Approval requirement satisfied. Repository verification has not run. Execution transport is disabled. Dispatch remains disabled.
- Current authority
- blocked platform
- Future execution
- disabled
Next controlled action
Approval requirement satisfied. Repository verification has not run. Execution transport is disabled. Dispatch remains disabled.. No automatic merge, posting, repository write, or agent execution follows from this recommendation.
GitHub Check Preview
ForgeLayer preview: merge blocked
Preview-only GitHub check status: completed/failure. Risk: HIGH. Recommendation: needs_human_review. ForgeLayer is not creating GitHub check runs yet.
Preview-only policy artifact, not current approval authority. ForgeLayer is not creating GitHub check runs yet.
- Conclusion
- failure
- Status
- completed
- Would block merge
- yes
- Check-preview policy flag
- required
PR Comment Preview v2
ForgeLayer Review
ForgeLayer reviewed acme-payments/payment-webhook-service#142. Risk is HIGH; merge recommendation is needs human review.
Copy-ready deterministic preview artifact, not current approval authority. GitHub posting is disabled by default. This is a copy-ready preview only. ForgeLayer is not calling GitHub APIs from this view.
Action items
Comment sections
headline
Headline
ForgeLayer Review
status
Status
GitHub posting is disabled by default. This is a copy-ready preview only.
risk summary
Risk Summary
HIGH
merge recommendation
Merge Recommendation
needs human review
required human checks
Required Human Checks
* security * owner
evidence needed
Evidence Needed
* Payment webhook behavior changed * Replay-protection evidence missing
changed files context
Changed Files / Context
Payment webhook changes are scoped to the webhook implementation and its matching test. Repository verification has not run; the approval requirement is satisfied.
next steps
Next Steps
* Resolve blocking findings. * Regenerate the ForgeLayer review before merge.
safety note
Safety Note
GitHub posting is disabled by default. Preview only unless GitHub posting is explicitly enabled. ForgeLayer does not call GitHub APIs from this preview surface. ForgeLayer does not execute agents, merge code, or grant repo access. Generic Platform Guidance: Human approval remains required before production merge.
Copy-ready markdown preview